Mini debate rubric pdf

This is by no means an authoritative source on how to teach your students. Student uses a wide array of the appropriate and accurate vocabulary in context. The student has clearly thought out the lesson and all the materials that are needed. Supporting reasons are not stated in main argument. Speaker point assessment rubric use half points 23. Philosophical debate needs work 1 not quite there 2 you did it 3 well doneimpressive 4 minimally evaluates a speakers point of view, reasoning, and use of evaluation of evidence and rhetoric, speakers point of view reasoning or exaggerated identifying any fallacious reasoning or exaggerated or distorted evidence. Use these worksheet to learn how to debate and how to prepare for a debate.

Participants may use research notes, as well as blank paper to make notes during the debate. But if they are clever enough to get away with what would a bunch of middleaged men know about this. The team made a clear presentation of the panelists basic position outstanding. Dimension comment possible points actual points made their conclusion clear 10 made their arguments logically 10 responded to the other sides arguments 10 remained focused on the important issues 10 used the course lecture material well 10. Various opinion matching exercisesworksheet with answers pdf opinion statements about relationships, mobile phones, advertising etc. You can create customized rubrics for primary, elementary, middle, and high school. These worksheets support higher level thinking in the classroom. Your debate rubric helps students see how they will be graded. Have at least 2 sides that can be reasonably supported with evidence be relevant to students and course material be simple enough to debate, yet complex. The teacher will share the rules of the mini debate with the class.

A scoring checklist for the actual debate is provided for. The goal of this lesson if to provide students the opportunity to practice the use of logic within a debate structure. Debate rubric 3 2 1 viewpoint viewpoints are clear and organized. Controversy informal model to encourage greater use of mini debates by teachers as a learning activity. This form can be used by both the teacher and student peers. A response that is very short negatively impacts other category scores stylecomplexity, vocabulary, grammarspelling, fluency, pronunciation due to insufficient evidence. Debate assessment rubric blm g15 debating team name and position. Minispeech performance assessment mrs hamilton ela. Rubrics to encourage formative and summative assessment between. Most information presented in the debate was clear and accurate, but.

Practical ideas for classroom debate revised fall 2003 the california high school speech association curriculum committee. Debate in the classroom kaneb center for teaching and. Grammar functions are used correctly with very few errors. Students will have time to prepare by reading the assigned section in the textbook and following the ten steps to effective research free rubric builder and assessment tools. Minispeech performance assessment you will be making a mini speech as one of the culminating projects of this unit. Showed confidence and preparation through body language, vocal inflection. The fishbowl debate randomly select a handful of students to come sit in front of the classroom in a halfcircle facing the students. Peer observation sheet gets students to write partners claims, counter arguments, evidence, and. Evidence for this score should be found in the specific points raised during the debate. By clearly expressing what excellence looks like, a rubric helps students understand what they need to work on. Having said the above, deduct marks for offensive ad hominem arguments. Essential tips for conducting a class debate busyteacher.

Two supporting reasons are stated in main argument. Each topic set should contain three to five related topics. Peer observation sheet gets students to write partners claims, counter arguments, evidence, and decorum. Rebuttal should contain reasonably valid arguments rather. Erbes points possible points earned mini lesson proposal the student clearly responds completely to each question in the proposal. This rubric is a helpful threat anytime you need a cooperative audience. Most information presented in the debate was clear, accurate and thorough. Youll find debate topics, information on how to debate and graphic organizers to help students organize their thinking around their debate. Most information presented in the debate was clear and.

Start by giving the new rubric a title and grade level. Controversy informal model to encourage greater use of minidebates by teachers as a. Debate outline rubric 30 points all outlines will be collected and graded based on the following rubric. The speakers statements clearly supported their position in the debate. Conducting a debate tn a debate is a discussion or structured contest about an issue or a resolution. Consider holding a practice debate early in the year. Evidencesupported minidebates common sense education. On the right side of the rubric, please write the number representing what you think was the performance level of the debate team in question for each criterion. Additionally, there may be things you want to add to this unit, delete, etc. Dimension comment possible points actual points made their conclusion clear 10 made their arguments logically 10 responded to the other sides arguments 10 remained focused on the. Debates may be judged in order to declare a winning side. Oral presentation rubric 4excellent 3good 2fair 1needs improvement delivery holds attention of entire audience with the use of direct eye contact, seldom looking at notes speaks with fluctuation in volume and inflection to maintain audience interest and emphasize key points consistent use of direct eye contact with. This guide is a brief compilation of teachingrelated information from several sources, including instructional guidebooks from other institutions, journals, and contributions from master teachers and academic support units at northern illinois university.

The teacher will share the rules of the minidebate with the class. Apply this rubric to any object and invite others to assess. Score description argumentation refutation structure presentation 21 and below. There are many different formats that you can use for your classroom debate. Erbes points possible points earned minilesson proposal the student clearly responds completely to each question in the proposal. There are some things, however, that all debate formats have in common. This table can be used to judge the quality and techniques other debaters are using to convey their points. Debate rubric criteria 1 2 3 4 5 roy rosenzweig center for.

Class debate rubrics by easy esl essentials teachers pay. Holding debates in middle school classes thoughtco. This can be a fun debate where students learn the mechanics of the debate activity and can practice with a topic that they might already know a lot about. Save hours of lesson preparation time with the entire busyteacher library. Debate rubric criteria 1 2 3 4 5 roy rosenzweig center. Position sheet for describing their position before and after the debate, and for recording questions note. A debate is a discussion or structured contest about an issue or a resolution. Such a debate is bound by rules previously agreed upon. Classroom debate worksheets for middles grades and high school. Delegate omits 3 of the criteria under 1 for a ranking of 4, and makes only one valuable contribution during the conference. Link, embed, and showcase your rubrics on your website.

Use the rubric on the back of this sheet to assign points. Debate rubric 2010 each student in the debate will be graded individually. To identify the faulty logic in other peoples arguments. When you make a rubric, you can use default text for a variety of existing performances, or create your content from scratch. Each partnership will have three minutes to debate. Delegate omits 2 of the criteria under 1 for a ranking of 4, and makes only two valuable contributions.

Here is some information for teachers who would like to introduce debate in their grades. Teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom. Student is uncomfortable with information and is able to answer only a few questions student shows a good understanding of parts of the topic. A topic set for the theme of mobile technology is shown here. Desks are lined up in two rows, facetoface, allowing the partners to go headtohead. Speech and deba te union teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom speech and deba te union page 3 of 29 pages generic debate format there are different types of debate and i t is important that you know what kind of debate yo u will be participati ng in.

Mini debate group project assignment project description drawing on the knowledge and skills you have learned so far in this unit, examine the services of bmo and cibc and argue which one is a better choice for high school and college students. This rubric category sets expectations for and assesses how well the student understands the debate topic. Pose a question or a statement to those selected students and ask them to discuss it. Students will have time to prepare by reading the assigned section in the textbook and following the ten steps to effective research. A quick introduction to debating in schools debating society.

To create a convincing argument based on logic and evidence. Spoke and acted in a suitable manner by demonstrating a clear understanding of topic, addressing pertinent issues with suitable language and decorum, conveying an appreciation of and respect for the audience. Rubric features categories for evidence, conduct, speaking, listening, and audience behavior. Three supporting reasons are stated in main argument. Remember that speaker points are not the same as points of information, and that the team that gets the highest speaker points does not have to be the team that wins the debate. These elements should be the guide to you eventual speaking rubric for. If using the student position handout, be sure to provide some time for completion of the initial position 3. Public forum debate lesson plans this is a suggested set of lesson plans that you could use to introduce your students to public forum pf debate. Instructional guide niu center for innovative teaching. Start at 22 and go up from there m i d d l e s c h o o l p u b l i c d e b a t e p r o g r a m middle school public debate program.